If I Were a “Secret Shopper” at Your Church This Weekend

If you read this blog regularly, you know that church consultants sometimes sends “spies” (what we call “secret shoppers”) to churches to give a report of their experience. They generally look for basic things – e.g., Is there adequate signage? Are the people friendly? Is the music well done? Is the preaching biblical? If I were to visit your church this weekend, though, here are some other things I’d watch for:

  • Does your church seem to be expecting guests? I can answer that question by whether your church has trained greeters in the parking lot, a manned welcome center, and friendly faces at the door. If your folks don’t know what to do with me when I get there, it will be clear they weren’t expecting me.
  • Does anyone ask me my name? Our experience is that “friendly” churches are friendly to people they already know – not necessarily to others. A wave, handshake, or “how are you?” cannot match a simple, “I don’t believe I know you. My name is _________. What’s yours?” 
  • Am I comfortable leaving my kids in your children’s area? Here are some things that would make me say, “no”: no adults in the room when we arrive; no check-in process that asks about my child’s allergies, etc.; no security process that seeks to assure my child’s safety; easy access for any adult to get to where my child is; rooms that seem cluttered, unprepared, and unsafe.
  • Does your church seem to enjoy singing God’s praises together? Here, I’m not concerned about the style of music as much as I am the fervor of the singing. I want to know if your congregation loves singing together. In most of our experiences, a church that doesn’t sing with passion usually has some underlying conflicts. 
  • Do your members have Bibles with them? The copy might be electronic or hard copy, but I still want to know that your members have their own Bible. That way, they make Bible study more personal and they model a walk with God for unchurched guests. I want inquirers and new believers to want to read the Bible, know it, and have their own copy.
  • If I were not a Christian, would I know at the end of the service how to become God’s child? It is our responsibility to proclaim the gospel clearly and passionately. Your church leaders might assume that’s happening at your church, but it’s often a non-believing guest in your church who can best answer this question.
  • Does the preaching clearly call me to respond to the Word in practical ways? Church leaders and scholars sometimes debate the preacher’s role in applying the Scriptures, but I’d argue that a sermon without application is an incomplete exposition of the text. I want you to push me to think about how my life should change based on the Word.
  • Would I turn to your church for prayer support based on my day with you? Is prayer so real, so powerful, and so recurrent when your church gathers that I’d turn to your congregation if I had a need? For too many churches, prayer is only the expected start and end of a small group, followed by being a filler in the service so people can move on and off the stage without being seen. It’s not in their DNA – and it shows.
  • Would I want to return to your church based on my one experience? I realize that evaluating a church on one experience may seem unfair, but many guests give our churches only that one opportunity. The question is thus an important one.
  • What kind of report do you think I’d give your church? 

    7 Comments

    • Chuck Lawless says:

      Thanks for your thoughts. 

    • Chuck Lawless says:

      There are good churches our there, Debbie. Blessings!

    • Jim says:

      The idea is to make the church better. A church that believes that it has no need to improve has already started to die. Can your church honestly answer “yes” to each of these points? If not, you have identified a need for improvement. But, you will not have the full picture even then.

      And, the reason for “spies” is that church members (particularly those who have been members for a long time) become blind to the problems in the church. You cannot know how someone coming to your church for the first time sees your church. You have the inside view. You are on the inside looking out. The only way to find out what it looks like to a person on the outside looking in is to bring someone in from outside. You need to remember that we are a witness to the world (whether we want to be or not). And, that witness can either be positive or negative.

      And, to the person seeking Jesus, it is important. It is only nonsense to those who feel that their comfort might be challenged.

      • Chuck Lawless says:

        Thanks, Jim.

        • Smallchurch Goer says:

          This is and endless disagreement

          “You cannot know how someone coming to your church for the first time sees your church.” No… I can not know how someone else feels, but nor can you. You can know only how you feel!

          You Mr. Lawless are judging a church by your standards. Who are you to decide what everyone who walks thru the church doors feels. How do you nominate yourself to be the knower and judger of a good church and a bad church? I can see quite clearly why our leaving pastor is a follower of your blogs and such, as he too has himself set on quite a high pedestal.

          “It is only nonsense to those who feel that their comfort might be challenged.”
          I would say this is wrong, but it’s not really wrong, it’s just your opinion. However in making that statement you are saying my opinion is wrong and I must correct you there Mr. Jim! My opinion that this “spy” ordeal is nonsense is not wrong… It’s my opinion. Also please note I have no fear of my comfort being challenged. You are simply stating that if I don’t agree with the church spy ordeal and with Mr. Lawless’ ideas of what a makes a good church then I’m wrong and that….. that is nonsense!

          Everyone who walks thru the doors of your church or mine, weather they be there for the 500th time or the 1st time has something different that they are going thru, something different on their heart and mind. You cannot say that you know what everyone who walks thru a church door feels, thinks or needs other than to say WE ALL NEED JESUS!

          To say a church is failing because it does not have someone standing there to greet you or signs telling you where to go, or you saw 5 people walk in and 2 were carrying bibles is ______________. (everyone has their own opinion)

          I agree to disagree.

    • Chuck Lawless says:

      Thanks, Cindy.

    Comments are closed.